TLDR
- Elijah Garcia (18-2, 14 KOs) will face undefeated Thomas O’Toole (16-0, 10 KOs) on December 5 in Glendale, Arizona
- The 10-round super middleweight bout headlines the prelims before David Benavidez vs Michal Cieslak
- Garcia is coming off a first-round knockout win over Ryan Adams in June
- O’Toole won his last fight in April, earning a unanimous decision over Jeremy Cullors for the WBA-NABA title
- The prelims stream live on DAZN and Prime Video starting at 6 p.m. ET / 3 p.m. PT
Sources: middleeasy.com | fightmag.com
Elijah Garcia will face unbeaten Thomas O’Toole in a 10-round super middleweight bout on December 5 at Desert Diamond Arena in Glendale, Arizona. Premier Boxing Champions announced the matchup on November 17, giving the Arizona fighter another home-state appearance.
The fight will headline the preliminary broadcast before David Benavidez’s cruiserweight unification with Michal Cieslak. The prelims start at 6 p.m. ET / 3 p.m. PT on DAZN and Prime Video, with the pay-per-view following at 8 p.m. ET.
โ BENAVIDEZ ๐ CIESLAK PRELIMS CONFIRMED
1๏ธโฃ Elijah Garcia ๐ Thomas OโToole – Super Middleweight
2๏ธโฃ Luis Nunez ๐ Toshiki Shimomachi – IBF Featherweight Title Eliminator pic.twitter.com/3sib0MH2Y5
— EverythingBoxing | Darshan Desai (@EverythingBoxi2) November 17, 2026
Garcia Returns After June Knockout Win
Garcia enters the fight with an 18-2 record and 14 knockouts. The 23-year-old southpaw last fought in June when he stopped Ryan Adams in the first round in Phoenix.
That victory came after a ten-round majority decision loss to Kevin Newman II in March. Garcia’s 2024 and 2025 record shows both wins and losses, starting with a split decision defeat to Kyrone Davis in June 2024.
He bounced back by beating Terrell Gausha over ten rounds in March 2025 before losing to Newman. The young fighter has proven he can compete in close fights that go the distance.
Garcia comes from a boxing family. His father George Jr. and grandfather George Sr. train him, and both boxed professionally. PBC describes him as a fourth-generation fighter.
His professional career began in Mexico in February 2020. Earlier in his career, Garcia stopped Amilcar Vidal in the fourth round in March 2023, defeated Kevin Salgado on points, and finished Armando Resendiz in round eight in September 2023.
O’Toole Brings Perfect Record to Arizona
O’Toole holds a 16-0 record with 10 knockouts. The 28-year-old southpaw is an Ireland-based Chicago native who has mixed stoppages with decision victories throughout his career.
He outpointed Javier Francisco Maciel over eight rounds in August 2024 and stopped Oscar Riojas in the third round that November. In February 2025, he halted James Perkins in round four.
O’Toole went the full ten rounds against Vaughn Alexander in June 2025, winning by unanimous decision. He then stopped Ismael Ocles in the fourth round in November 2025.
His most recent fight came in April when he defeated Jeremy Cullors for the vacant WBA-NABA super middleweight title. The fight in Medford, Massachusetts went the full ten rounds, with O’Toole winning by unanimous decision on scorecards of 99-91, 97-93, and 96-94.
O’Toole previously fought at cruiserweight, facing opponents like Joe Jones, Miguel Angel Cobas, and Scott Lampert. He knocked out both Cobas and Lampert in the first round before moving to super middleweight.
The December 5 card also features a 12-round IBF featherweight title eliminator between Luis Nunez and Toshiki Shimomachi on the prelims. Nunez holds a 24-0 record with 16 knockouts, while Shimomachi has a 23-1-3 record with 12 knockouts.
Nunez last fought in May when he stopped Carlos Roberto Perez Perez in the fourth round. Shimomachi also fought in May, winning a majority decision against Reiya Abe.
The main card features Nikita Tszyu’s U.S. debut against Roberto Valenzuela Jr. in a super welterweight bout. Tszyu carries a 12-0-1 record with 10 knockouts into the fight.




>